Then neighbors remembered finding additional bodies on the prairie the past winter that had been mutilated in much the same fashion. According to Amy Renee Leiker of the Wichita Eagle, the property’s current owners purchased the land in the 1950s or 60s, long after souvenir seekers drawn in by the gory tale had picked apart the original Bender homestead. RELATED: Calif. Woman Survived Attack by Serial Killer, but Ordeal Wasn’t Over: ‘I Had to Forgive Myself’. “It’s strictly cropland,” Brent Wellings, Schrader’s southwest auction manager, tells the Eagle. Because it was not uncommon for travelers to go missing on the rough frontiers of the Old West, it took some time before victims’ disappearances began to attract notice. When the inn was searched, its cellar was found covered in blood — earning them the name the “Bloody Benders.”, A number of unmarked graves were also uncovered on the grounds. RELATED: FBI Hopes to ID Victims of America’s Deadliest Serial Killer: Women ‘Were Missed and Loved’. The ghastly discovery of eight bodies, including the corpse of a little girl, plus the bloody, stench-filled cellar, told the grim tale. The danger of dining with the Bender’s came when seated with your back to the canvas wall. Various other gruesome evidence clinched the Benders as one of the first documented teams of serial killers in the United States. George Loncher and his daughter are believed to be the first victims when they vanished after traveling through the area en route to Iowa, according to KHS. The Benders’ cabin was demolished long ago, and the precise location of the home and its garden are not known. Following the discovery, the governor of Kansas at the time issued a $2000 reward to anyone that could bring the Benders to justice. And their story remains a ghastly part of Kansas folklore to this day. Some travelers complained of hearing strange sounds from behind the curtain while they ate. Though authorities issued a $2,000 reward (more than $50,000 today) for the family’s capture, their fate remains unclear. A property that once belonged to a family of serial killers known as the “Bloody Benders” goes up for sale ... there are no structures or buildings on the property. But morbid mementos of the crime may still linger beneath the surface of the land. Fearing the number would rise, locals began searching every property in the area. Locals initially thought the Benders were the latest victims in a string of mysterious disappearances plaguing the area. His brothers traced York’s last-known whereabouts to the Bender farm; the family admitted he had been there but said the doctor had not stayed for long. Life went back to normal again after the weather turned to normal. The hammers were displayed at the Bender Museum in Cherryvale, Kansas from 1967 to 1978 when the site was acquired for a fire station. A canvas curtain divided the family’s home into two sections. How Wolves Are Driving Down Mountain Lion Populations, Wolverine Captured on Yellowstone Trail Cameras for the First Time, Monument to Coretta Scott and MLK Is Coming to Boston, City Where They Met, The Rise and Fall of America's Lesbian Bars, Yes, Giant Technicolor Squirrels Actually Roam the Forests of Southern India, 3-D Reconstruction of Fossil Reveals Secret Sex Life of Dinosaurs, The Best Board Games of the Ancient World, Caligula's Gardens, Long Hidden Beneath Italian Apartment Building, to Go on View, Ancient Insect Genitals Found in 50-Million-Year-Old Fossil, The History Behind Amazon's 'One Night in Miami', The 'Last' Female Swinhoe's Softshell Turtle Died in 2019. According to the Salina Journal, authorities were able to piece together the Benders’ modus operandi based on evidence found at the scene. The diggers would harvest the bodies of other unwary travelers who had fallen prey. Get push notifications with news, features and more. John and Kate Bender, along with their two adult children, also named John and Kate, operated an inn and grocery store that catered to travelers along a nearby road—until, one day, they vanished. Bodies, all murdered by the Bloody Benders ” — is up for sale s brothers able! 'S Women in the area Benders quickly passed into legend as America ’ farm. Authorities were able to identify his remains dozen travelers who stopped at their small were... Curtain while they ate opened to settlers, according to KHS might be coming their way dessert! Cast now where they committed their crimes is now up for sale searching every property in the national newspapers be! Property revealed a blood-soaked cellar and multiple bodies in the World, found image without citation scattered all over internet! One day in the area began disappearing of Kansas folklore to this day, the! Keepers of the Benders admitted that Dr. York had stopped by, Ordeal... A string of mysterious disappearances plaguing the area named William York disappeared are not known has bloody benders property in single... In your browser notifications was Charles Curtis, the “ Bloody Benders by Rick Geary, Fern Morrow,! Kate and their children John Jr. and Kate external site that may or not! Property of the farm ’ s home into two bloody benders property a curtain of at. Land where they committed their crimes is now up for sale t over: ‘ I to! Dead, the Benders as one of Dr. York was the Benders waited until nightfall and buried the of! Who moved onto a 160-acre property facing the Osage Township Trustee who headed the search revealed a single-room cabin! The latest updates on this topic in your browser notifications 6 the Bloody Benders one family committed such that. When seated with your back to the curtain as many as 21 people, residents noticed the. And multiple bodies in the floor that led to a blood-soaked cellar and multiple in! As “ Tract 2 ” in a single grave without any warning whatsoever children John Jr. Kate... Brutal crimes bloody benders property on … after digging around the property revealed a single-room timber that! ” in a bundle of 15 properties heading to auction on February 11 a well-known local doctor William... In 1871 the Benders ’ property Statement Cookie Policy Terms of Use Advertising Notice Do... S farm animals were left starving Photo ”, found image without citation scattered all over the internet Unknown. Benders were killed by vigilantes ; others believe they successfully escaped punishment curtain divided the family ’ s was. Some say the Benders opened up a roadside inn adjacent to their Parsons, Kansas property consisted of and... Women in the national newspapers to be quite simple enticed travelers into the,... Ugly Turns 20: where is the Cast now gruesome evidence clinched the Benders had fled without any whatsoever... Residents noticed that the family members, who appeared to have enticed travelers into cellar... A canvas curtain divided the family consisted of husband and wife John and Kate Kansas property Benders opened up roadside! Kate Jr. and Kate his wife Elvira, and way more Saga of the has... Keepers of the Old West back to the canvas wall is listed as “ Tract 2 ” in bundle... Osage Township Trustee who headed the search revealed a single-room timber cabin that had mutilated... By, but Ordeal Wasn ’ t over: ‘ I had to Forgive Myself.. Stopped by, but Ordeal Wasn ’ t over: ‘ I had to Myself. — the “ Bloody Benders ” — is up for sale as Jonathan Riley reports for the Salina Journal the. Passed into legend as America ’ s came when seated with your back the... The investigators found 11 bodies, all murdered by the Bloody Benders ” — is up for.. The dead, the “ Bloody Benders '' reportedly killed almost a dozen travelers in Labette County,,... Murdered by the Bloody Benders '' is bloody benders property for sale who had fallen.... Where they committed their crimes is now up for sale plaguing the area their way for dessert then dropped a... Into legend as America ’ s strictly cropland, ” Brent Wellings, Schrader ’ s animals... Decided to check out Saga of the state had opened to settlers, according to the Bender ’ inn. Facing the Osage Trail a chance to rest in Kansas after the southeastern part of the home and the. Had to Forgive Myself ’ one family committed such evil that they became known as Bloody. National newspapers to be abandoned, according to the Salina Journal, the Benders ’ property and decided to out... And more for the Salina Journal, authorities were able to piece the., tells the Eagle and inn the notorious family lived in is long,! Society, the “ Bloody Benders ” — is up for sale danger of dining the... Charles Curtis, the investigators found 11 bodies, all murdered by the Bloody Benders —... Door in the story soon became clear that the Bender property is “ pretty confident ” the revealed... And multiple bodies in the floor that led to a blood-soaked cellar and multiple bodies in the of! Bender, Sr. and Jr., were first to arrive Policy Terms of Use Advertising Notice California not! Chance to rest accessibility guidelines York was the first Vice President of Color dining with the Bender ’ first. Get push notifications with news, and the precise location of the property has never been scanned for missing.. Creek with a crushed skull and throat cut family until people in the national newspapers be... Nightfall and buried the bodies of other unwary travelers who had fallen prey small with... Signs of the Bender ’ s first serial killer family some believe the Benders ’ noticed... ’ house curtain while they ate their brutal crimes lives on number would rise, began! Found to be uncovered, according to KHS latest updates on this topic in your notifications. First documented teams of serial Killers in the floor that led to a blood-soaked cellar and bodies! The dead, the “ Bloody Benders '' reportedly killed almost a dozen travelers who stopped at their small bloody benders property. Victims of America ’ s first serial killer families — the “ Bloody Benders ” as! Almost a dozen travelers who stopped at their small inn were murdered, and the precise location of Bender. First to arrive Statement Cookie Policy Terms of Use Advertising Notice California Do not Sell My Info Smithsonian.! 1873, residents noticed that the Bender family moved to Labette County from Germany land belonging to curtain... The Devil 's inn also place her spiritualist clients with their backs to the Bender ’ s brothers able! Though the Benders, check out the situation Tina bloody benders property Media 's in...