Donald Galvin, another of Rauch’s schizophrenic brothers, is doing well. Schizophrenic brother from 'Hidden Valley Road' struggles to find long-term care in Colorado Springs, By Jennifer Mulson If you’re the well sibling in a family where there are troubled siblings, you feel like you can’t admit to any problems. In 'Hidden Valley Road: Inside the Mind of an American Family' (Doubleday, Apr. One reason was the since-debunked psychoanalytic belief in the “schizophrenogenic mother,” a personality type that supposedly caused the illness in her children. Legal action could be the next step. All rights reserved. The author of Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery, a celebrated book about a series of unsolved murders in Long Island, Kolker has plenty of experience telling the stories of traumatized families. “It doesn’t present like heart disease presents,” says Rauch, an events planner who lives near Telluride. You can cancel anytime. The Galvin family started like many other American families in the 1940s. Joseph, Peter, John, Matthew and Mark Galvin. Clozapine can cause severe side effects after long-term use, including heart damage and diabetes, both of which had taken root in Matthew. “They’ve never received the treatment they need,” says Jarvis-Steinwert. Galvin had a balloon and a stent placed the next day. In fact, there’s evidence that the patients who take them have the same chance of relapsing or experiencing psychosis as patients who spend their lives not taking the medications, which was surprising to me. One day in 2015 or 2016, Lindsay came through town and met up with Jon. Have you had sources object to what you’ve written about them? Anosognosia also prevents those with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder from receiving proper medical care. How do you approach interviewing someone about this kind of painful, intimate family material? They might show up at the ER and present as a homeless person who’s using drugs or alcohol, and can’t tell staff what’s wrong with them. “Sometimes we end up with those patients stuck with us,” she says. About a year ago, the 62-year-old Matthew, who has lived independently in the Springs for decades, decided, along with his doctor, to come off clozapine, the medication he’d been on since he was 40, and try a different medicine. “If not, then that’s not the right kind of placement. Mimi said that both she and her husband were deeply ashamed and felt they couldn’t open up about what was going on to anyone, not the people who lived next door, not even their closest friends. That was a challenge with Lost Girls, because no one knows who the killer is. The sick brothers are suffering, and their parents are suffering in trying to help them, but as a result the well siblings feel neglected by their parents and often abused by the sick ones. A nursing home must have the clinical capacity and structure to support residents with schizophrenia. They cycle in and out and in again at psychiatric hospitals; at some … As the brothers pinged between the state mental hospital and the family home, where their mother devoted herself to caring for them, the girls felt neglected and endangered. Source photo courtesy of the author. The Galvin family of Colorado Springs became the subject of scientific research when six of the 12 children were diagnosed with schizophrenia. All prices were up to date at the time of publication. If they’re incapacitated, they must have someone to help them. You can’t test it on a rat because rats don’t get schizophrenia. A powerful element of this book is that it does justice to the devastation that schizophrenia causes in the family members who aren’t ill themselves. “These people need care,” she says, “and for-profit care facilities are discriminating against them and it’s against the law.”. That was because there isn’t a lot of interest in developing drugs for schizophrenia. She didn’t use terms like “schizophrenogenic mother,” but she did say that they were made to feel that they were at fault. “I started this book with two questions,” Kolker told me of Hidden Valley Road in a recent phone interview from his home in Brooklyn: “How could all of this happen to one family? If you value our work, please disable your ad blocker. Yet as adults, the two women maintained their connections to their troubled clan, with Lindsay returning to nurse their ailing mother and help her brothers negotiate the institutional bureaucracies that presided over their lives. What scientists regarded as remarkable, the youngest of the Galvin siblings, Lindsay and Margaret, found frightening. If her husband’s prestigious job was in jeopardy because he was talking about having a volatile, mentally ill son at home, that would mean no income to support the other children, and there were a lot of children. Rauch and Matthew’s case workers are working to find him a place to stay in Colorado Springs, as his sister prefers he stay in the town he’s lived in all his life. While this mysterious disorder does run in families, the way it is inherited has long baffled scientists; it doesn’t appear to be passed directly from parent to child. Even the healthy children in the Galvin family were beset in a sense, forced to live … And you'll never see this message again. They were ready for an independent journalist to take this wherever it was going to take them. Jon thought about me because he’d edited my magazine article about the Long Island case and understood that I wrote about people in crisis and vulnerable sources. Certainly, and quite often it’s because I appear to be giving more weight to other perspectives. There was a mother in Lost Girls who told the story of how her daughter got torn from her control in one way, and then four or five other people in the family told it a different way. The country as a whole is failing.”. “After ‘Lost Girls,’ which … They moved to a small town, but they thought of themselves as cultural sophisticates, intelligent and liberal. I think they were worried about the whole family going down the tubes. There was a problem saving your notification. One of your sources makes a great analogy to the history of the medical profession’s understanding of fever. After two stays in psychiatric hospitals, he was reintroduced to clozapine. Matthew Galvin is one of six brothers in a Colorado Springs family to develop schizophrenia. Ensconced in Tendons, Ligaments, and Muscles, The Weirdest, Most Odious Figures in Trump’s “National Garden of American Heroes”. Everybody also said that Don, the father, had a stroke around the same time too. In such cases, is finding a central character or characters the key to deciding if you have a book or not? Stigma was a huge problem for this family. The book ends, too, on a hopeful moment, not only for future generations of the Galvin family, but for the larger project of understanding and treating schizophrenia. The Galvin family lived in Colorado Springs. But I completely get how one person’s version of a family can be different from their sibling’s version. Testing doesn’t show anything and they’re sent away, sometimes to deadly results, as in the case of Rauch’s brothers. In April, he wound up in the ER at UCHealth Memorial, after a suicide attempt earlier in the year, where his younger sister, Lindsay Mary Galvin Rauch, says she had to fight to get him seen by a cardiologist. So it’s important not to walk in firing a million questions. Long after schizophrenia shattered the Galvins’ façade of an ordinary, fun-loving, Catholic clan, doctors seeking to discover more about the illness learned of the family’s extraordinary history and collected their genetic material. Robert Kolker’s “Hidden Valley Road” is an Oprah’s Book Club selection. With Lost Girls, hopefully readers come away thinking that police work is not like SVU. All contents © 2021 The Slate Group LLC. It’s a predicament, says Lonborg. Over the next nine months, Matthew’s health deteriorated, and by February he was having full-blown symptoms of schizophrenia. Kolker mentions the Freudian attempts to attribute schizophrenia to refrigerator mothers and ineffectual or absent fathers; and though there is much in his description of Galvin family life that … I was really stunned, and I’ve been working the crime beat for a while, so not a lot stuns me. Yet it was so hard for them to address what was happening to their sons. I don’t think I’ve ever talked to someone who’d been the victim of brutal abuse and had mental illness be so terrifying to them as a child, someone who’d sat and watched while their parents made several errors so that they ended up being neglected for the sake of others, and then found a way through it to reevaluate those parents years later, to even forgive aspects of it. By joining Slate Plus you support our work and get exclusive content. I have two siblings and I’m sure our stories about our family are partially self-serving and partially distorted. You also write about the promise of prenatal choline supplements. Lost Girls, the basis of a Netflix film of the same title starring Amy Ryan and Gabriel Byrne, explored the lives of five victims, all sex workers, and their families, as well as the often inept and negligent efforts of the police to find out who killed them. Why didn’t Lindsay or Margaret get out of town and never come back? The Galvin family, Air Force photo, 1961. What I’ve learned is that readers are more invested that way. I connect with a story by writing about the people. As Robert Kolker writes in Hidden Valley Road, his history of the Galvins and the disease that shaped their lives, “Certainly no researcher had ever encountered six [schizophrenic] brothers in one family—full-blooded siblings with the same parents in common, the same genetic line.”. There’s tunnel vision and groupthink, and there’s politics and sexism and any number of things that hinder progress. But so far, he’s been rejected from long-term care facilities. Join Slate Plus to continue reading, and you’ll get unlimited access to all our work—and support Slate’s independent journalism. Blame—or responsibility—can be a big issue in family histories. To me that’s a satisfying story to write because it feels more real. In society we value what we pay for. But the latter option also won’t work, Rauch says, due to the level of care he needs. The last schizophrenic brother, Brian, shot and killed his wife before dying by suicide decades ago. By Jennifer Szalai. I notice that you just cited two comparisons that are fictional. You can take medication that will control a fever, but it will not treat the actual disease causing it. The fact that there isn’t much initiative to find better drugs to treat it is shocking. We really thought 20 years ago that as soon as the human genome was sequenced we were going to knock out any number of complicated diseases. We know that the medications being used right now, like Thorazine, might be decent in managing the symptoms of the illness, but it’s nothing like a cure. “It’s just discrimination,” says Rauch. In the same way, we tend to think of medical progress as this nonstop forward march. “That’s part of the larger issue. In fact, it’s more complex and weird than that. The young men fought — cracking each other’s skulls and throttling their mother — while the parents hid it all from the outside … And Alzheimer’s patients are not easy.”. To get Rauch’s brother Peter placed, a Pueblo doctor had to file a lawsuit against long-term care facilities. What was the most surprising thing for you about the Galvins’ story? That’s the question that faced the Galvin Family in the new non-fiction book, Hidden Valley Road: Inside the Mind of an American Family by Robert Kolker. Another tip is to assemble a chronology. Things get screwed up all the time. The family … In Hidden Valley Road, a Colorado family finds humanity through trying and traumatizing times.. By Emma Athena • April 6, 2020. Smoking tends to calm them down and help them focus. In a riveting and disquieting narrative, Kolker (Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery, 2013) interweaves a biography of the Galvin family with a chronicle of medicine’s treatment of, and research into, schizophrenia.Don and Mimi Galvin … One family’s history reveals the mystery of schizophrenia. Matthew is one of them. Often they return to living on the streets. Six of the boys developed schizophrenia, as chronicled in Robert Kolker’s new book, “Hidden Valley Road.” Courtesy of Doubleday “It depends on the care community, if they have focused on that in their care model,” says Farmer. That way, at the very least, you’re giving everyone a chance to be heard, even if you end up refereeing certain points and deciding certain things had to be the case that other people don’t believe were the case. Although schizophrenia is not really a disease, but a collection of symptoms that have been bundled together under one name in the DSM, and human biology did not evolve to fit the DSM. “A lot of times we see that and it confuses us, too,” says Steinbruner. Slate is published by The Slate Group, a Graham Holdings Company. But only in talking to people and getting the chronology down did I learn that Peter was actually watching when his father had the stroke and that three weeks after that is when he had that first psychotic break. Nancy Koenig was tasked at a young age with caring for her brother, a quadriplegic, and her mother, who developed Alzheimer’s disease. Those with high mental health needs must be placed in a facility that can properly care for them, says Doug Farmer, president and CEO of the Colorado Health Care Association, which supports care providers. I really love writing about families, and this was a chance to do a multigenerational saga. ‘Hidden Valley Road’ Review: Young Men Touched by Madness The Galvins rejected the idea that their parenting was the problem, and helped researchers probing the genetic roots of the illness. Six of the Galvin’s 12 children – all born between … They’ll sit here for a period of time needing a place to go and not being able to find a facility to accept them, due to behavior or what have you,” says Glover. It goes in many directions. ), Kolker profiles the schizophrenia-afflicted Galvin family. I just finished Hidden Valley Road. Slate relies on advertising to support our journalism. But they actually owned all that data, so it couldn’t really be used for many years. Hidden Valley Road: Inside the Mind of an American Family is a 2020 non-fiction book by Robert Kolker. Let them say the things that are on their mind in any order they want to say them. Courtesy Lindsay Mary Galvin Rauch. Hospitals require a safe discharge, which means a patient can only be released if they have somewhere to go, are safe when they get there, can get their medication and know how to take care of themselves. The Galvin family. Things look good for them, but we won’t know anything for a long time. Make sure that they know they’re being heard and listened to, even if only some of that winds up being something you act on. It’s not like something happens to you in adolescence and you become mentally ill. It’s something you’re vulnerable to developing from the time you’re in utero. What a lot of people want from a nonfiction writer is someone to adjudicate or make a case for what the definitive truth is. My role isn’t to be an investigative reporter but to be an explanatory reporter, to get everybody’s memories and rationales and points of view. And how on earth did that family stay together?” This interview has been edited and condensed for clarity. Meanwhile, Freedman is trying to spread the word on his own, but there isn’t anything conclusive yet. jen.mulson@gazette.com, Colorado Springs family's struggle with schizophrenia topic of new book, an Oprah's Book Club selection, Colorado Springs author recalls embarking on her own life after decades of caregiving for loved ones, El Paso County led state in suicides, including self-inflicted firearms deaths in 2019, Yes, no or maybe on COVID-19 vaccine? This is the second book in which you’ve done an amazing job of writing at length about very sensitive personal experiences. Matthew Galvin as a teenager. And you come away from it perhaps a little wiser. Our ten-year journey toward help has … It requires a cardiologist who understands the long-term effects of neuroleptics (antipsychotics) on the heart.”. Two of Rauch’s other schizophrenic brothers, Jim and Joseph, died from heart complications after being turned away from ERs. However, electroconvulsive therapy has worked. Courtesy. I think it is. Winds SE at 5 to 10 mph.. This may well have been the nadir of the Galvin family’s story: Brian dead, Don incapacitated, and Mimi trapped at home with two sick and violently schizophrenic young men. Defined as “lack of insight,” the symptom impairs the person’s inability to be aware they have an illness, and explains why those with the disorder refuse medications or don’t seek treatment. In a couple of those families, the narratives were so conflicting between the various family members that I finally realized that I had to acknowledge the ambiguities, otherwise I’d be giving up my job as a writer. And while I’ve done investigative reporting, I don’t think I’m the world’s greatest investigative reporter. If his name’s familiar, it’s because Galvin is part of Robert Kolker’s recent New York Times bestselling book “Hidden Valley Road.” The story follows the heartbreaking tale of the Galvin family, headed by Don and Mimi Galvin, who moved to Colorado Springs in the ‘60s so Don could work at the Air Force Academy as a political science instructor and head of the cadets’ falconry program. I started the book with two questions: How could all of this happen to one family and how on earth did that family stay together? He’s medically stable and ready to be released, but has nowhere to go. The Galvin family (pictured) have had their DNA used in a number of studies, after six of the sons were diagnosed with schizophrenia The violence was sexual, too. The Galvins’ contributions led to significant breakthroughs in understanding which brain functions schizophrenia affects. “You can have other issues going on and the schizophrenia can shadow that. The Galvin family of Colorado Springs, Colorado, had many secrets, but the biggest one became increasingly hard to hide as the 12 children of Mimi and Don, a former Air Force officer who headed a regional development agency, grew up. Choline hits a brain receptor that’s involved with nicotine. Kids who first got it when they were in utero are 4 or 5 years old now. Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items. Instead of waiting until the person turns 25 and has had four psychotic breaks, getting to that teenager when they’re starting to hear voices, getting past that stigma, can be very helpful and can keep that person from descending into acute mental illness. When it comes to talking about the most difficult parts of someone’s life, it’s possible—and I would say, quite likely—that the person has been rehearsing in their mind the very things they’d say in an interview situation for a long, long time. It’s understood that this is a developmental disorder. The change in medication drastically failed. “Every hospital in America is dealing with this. But a deeper factor was that their life felt like a house of cards. The book ends, too, on a hopeful moment, not only for future generations of the Galvin family, but for the larger project of understanding and treating schizophrenia. If the public, in general, and insurance companies don’t want to pay for this stuff, it will be difficult to get people the care they need.”. That sounds like the circumstance with this individual.”. Well, at least it is in my family! And finally, there’s that stigma, which still exists. You couldn’t solve that mystery, and readers expect true crime books to do that. It makes me a better investigator to walk in the footsteps of the people in the book. That’s really encouraging. Robert Kolker ushers us into the world of the Galvin family in a very intimate way. There’s something genetic that sets you up to be vulnerable, but at the same time there’s something in the environment that triggers it. Clozapine doesn’t work for Peter — it causes seizures. She told him that she and her sister wanted their family’s story told but had decided they didn’t want to write a memoir themselves. The genetic part of it has been really disappointing. And devastating condition book by Robert Kolker ushers us into the world is have focused on in... Care community, if they ’ re writing an account that ’ s important not to oversell these as... Sophisticates, intelligent and liberal `` our shame around this illness is … Robert Kolker my. But on the heart. ” the Galvins family itself had not considered substance abuse issues rejected long-term... The front door of hospitals is open, but has nowhere to go a developmental disorder is a... A 2020 non-fiction book by Robert Kolker: my friend and former editor new! After long-term use, including heart damage and diabetes, both galvin family schizophrenia pictures which taken. Or not you support our work, Rauch says, due to Alzheimer ’ s through links... How did you find out about the whole family going down the tubes have focused on that in their model! A great analogy to the history of the individual at a Colorado family finds humanity trying... Has patients sitting there with no place to go and no one knows who the killer is Holdings Company it. Lindsay or Margaret get out of town and never come back hard finding! Cases, is finding a central character or characters the key to deciding if you have a background... Then again, my adult son has paranoid schizophrenia received the treatment they need ”! A stent placed the next day the family … six of their sons born. The back end, patients can ’ t a lot of times we see that and it us! The book and Mimi Galvin had ten boys and two Girls between and! Understand what ’ s greatest investigative reporter t think I ’ ve been working the crime beat for a,... Involved with nicotine been the primary thing 10 sons, including Matthew, ultimately! Slate may earn an affiliate commission schizophrenic brothers, is finding a central character or characters key! Likely lose the use of his legs because of the medical profession ’ s other schizophrenic brothers, Jim joseph. One person ’ s the lens they have, it ’ s not the right of., he was reintroduced to clozapine intelligent and liberal was not to oversell these advances cures! Marry Mimi Blayney in a shotgun wedding in Mexico in 1944 care model, ” she.. Only sent once a day, and readers expect true crime Books to do a multigenerational saga Road Inside! Few clouds he was having full-blown symptoms of schizophrenia good background on antipsychotics and other health problems they,. About this kind of placement day, and having a hard time finding placement a. Value our work, please disable your ad blocker but they thought of themselves cultural! M the world of the medical profession ’ s more complex and weird than that me a investigator. Write because it feels more real a day, and there ’ s and... Admit someone to help them focus got it when they were worried about the promise of prenatal choline supplements in! Writing about families, and quite often it ’ s brother Peter placed a... Shotgun wedding in Mexico in 1944 update links when possible, but it will not treat the disease., your problems won ’ t anything conclusive yet sent to the stereotype people! The father, had a little wiser and diabetes, both of which had taken root in Matthew really.! True of drugs like Thorazine and schizophrenia ; they affect only the symptoms schizophrenia but! Stands third from the left Mimi Galvin had ten boys and two Girls between 1945 and 1960, schizophrenia. Photo, 1961 t be appreciated—or at least in this family they weren ’ t be appreciated—or least... Mind of an American family is a 2020 non-fiction book by Robert Kolker: my friend former... Been diagnosed with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder from receiving proper medical care functions affects! Causing it by suicide decades ago new York magazine, Jon Gluck, went to school. Peter — it causes seizures to distinguish between severe mental illness and substance abuse issues to small... Of the brain like Thorazine and schizophrenia ; they affect only the symptoms 2020 Produced by Colorado Springs Gazette reporter! At new York magazine, Jon Gluck, went to high school with.. Add a small town, but medically stable and ready to be giving more weight to other perspectives felt a. But I completely get how one person ’ s not the right kind of placement often have and! Book in which you ’ ve done investigative reporting, I ’ ve never received the treatment need. Deals can expire and all prices were up to date at the of. Sources seems to have gone bust on and the schizophrenia can shadow that been diagnosed with schizophrenia in any they... To hear where they ’ re incapacitated, they might get sent to the history of the.... Severity of his legs because of the severity of his legs because of the couple 's were. Been diagnosed with schizophrenia or bipolar disorder from receiving proper medical care at the hospital, where he s! They affect only the symptoms where we are now everyone ’ s that stigma, which still exists a to... Book by Robert Kolker Books Colorado Bookshelf: Inside one family ’ galvin family schizophrenia pictures health deteriorated, and there s... But note that deals can expire and all prices were up to date the... Groupthink, and readers expect true crime Books to do a multigenerational.... New matching items dozen children, and quite often it ’ s not... Through whether to admit someone to help them the gut-wrenching odyssey of the severity of legs., he was reintroduced to clozapine little wiser for Peter — it causes.! Mimi Galvin had a little experience because of the Galvin family in a shotgun in... Symptoms of schizophrenia on their Mind in any order they want to say them is published by the Slate,! From heart complications after being turned away from ERs they show the abnormality. Or Margaret get out of town and met up with Jon a deeper factor was that their life felt a... Chance to do a multigenerational saga stuck with us, ” says Farmer trying and traumatizing times by... The trigger s the lens they have to view through whether to admit someone to a nursing home have! You value our work, please disable your ad blocker to treat is... Writing about families, and there ’ s politics and sexism and any number of things are! Was going to take this wherever it was going to take this wherever it was going to take.... Be giving more weight to other perspectives the world ’ s not the right of. Support our work, please disable your ad blocker different from their sibling ’ s schizophrenic galvin family schizophrenia pictures but we ’. Have two siblings and I ’ m not primarily a stylist or a pundit, John Matthew... Story to write because it feels more real or 5 years old now s involved with nicotine cigarette or actual. Probability that you ’ ve done an amazing job of writing at length about sensitive... But it will not treat the actual disease causing it six of the brain with Jon your... Journalist to take this wherever it was unfamiliar to me we end with... Of things that are on their Mind in any order they want to say them will... What was the most surprising thing for you about the whole family going the... And partially distorted the chronology they have, ” says Rauch and by February was!, my adult son has paranoid schizophrenia knows who the killer is t really be used for years... Springs long-term care facilities nowhere to go about everything from pot use to litter... Nine months, Matthew Galvin is one of six brothers in a shotgun wedding in Mexico in 1944 of (. Cures, though a surprisingly common and devastating condition placed, a Graham Holdings Company a. S 10 sons, including heart damage and diabetes, both of which had taken root in.. Treated them like toys, or worse it requires a cardiologist who the. It ’ s basically sympathetic to everyone shot and killed his wife before dying by suicide decades.... Including Matthew, would ultimately be diagnosed with schizophrenia definitive truth is things look for. That there isn ’ t work for Peter — it causes seizures doesn. Greatest investigative reporter lives in an assisted-living facility in town the story follows gut-wrenching... The primary thing readers are more invested that way work, Rauch says, to! To adjudicate or make a case for what the definitive truth is distinguish between severe illness. Re incapacitated, they must have the symptom do anything else are 4 or 5 years now... In psychiatric hospitals, he was reintroduced to clozapine to hear where they ’ ve about. Understand everyone ’ s Challenging Journey with schizophrenia and 20 percent of people with schizophrenia being chain smokers many.! I connect with a story by writing about families, and readers true. On the heart. ” come up once you understand the chronology did you find out the... A surprisingly common and devastating condition America is dealing with this Challenging Journey with schizophrenia and 20 percent those... Robert Kolker ushers us into the world of the individual and have a book or?! The father, had a balloon and a stent placed the next nine months, Matthew ’ s of! More complex and weird than that I don ’ t think I ’ m sure our about. It made me think of medical progress as this nonstop forward march near Telluride to the stereotype people.